The Challenges of Dementia Caregiving: When the Relationship Changes

Over the past few blogs, I’ve been writing about grief, and I’ve been wanting to return to another area I’ve been focusing on in my practice: older adult counselling and the challenges that can come with aging and dementia.

In previous posts, I’ve talked about some of the changes and concerns that can accompany aging and dementia. In this blog, I want to turn my attention to another important part of that picture—the caregiver.

When we think about someone living with dementia, there is often another person quietly walking alongside them. It may be a spouse or partner, an adult child, sibling, friend, or sometimes a professional caregiver or organization. Whoever takes on that role, caregiving can become a significant part of their life.

A Note About Caregiving

Although this blog focuses particularly on dementia caregiving, I want to be clear that my intention is not to minimize the experience of anyone caring for a loved one with other physical or mental health challenges. Caregiving can take many forms, and each situation brings its own challenges, rewards, losses, and uncertainties.

Much of what I talk about in this series—the emotional weight, changing relationships, exhaustion, grief, and need to care for yourself—can apply to many different caregiving situations. My hope is that whether you are caring for someone with dementia or supporting a loved one in another way, you will find something here that speaks to your own experience.

How Do We Become a Caregiver?

Sometimes caregiving is a role we enter almost without realizing it.

For a spouse or partner, there may be the familiar commitment made in marriage: “in sickness and in health, until death do us part.” When we make those promises, we usually aren’t imagining what those words might look like decades later.

Most of us enter relationships assuming, perhaps without consciously thinking about it, that we will grow old together and somehow face the end of life at the same time. The reality, of course, is that this rarely happens.

Eventually, one person may find themselves becoming the caregiver.

If it isn’t a spouse or partner, it may be an adult child. Sometimes it falls to a sibling or friend. In other circumstances, professional caregivers, assisted living, or other supportive services become an important part of providing care.

Regardless of how someone comes into the role, caregiving is something most of us have relatively little experience preparing for.

My Own Experience With Caregiving

My own experiences with caregiving have given me some personal insight into the demands of this role.

I had some experience caring for my mother and later had a much more involved caregiving experience with both my mother- and father-in-law, as well as my dad. My dad lived with us for several months, and during that time I was his primary caregiver.

All of them eventually died at home, except for my mother, who had a very brief hospital stay before her death.

Those experiences are another story for another blog, but they gave me firsthand glimpses into the physical and emotional exhaustion that can come with an extended caregiving role.

I’m a little reluctant to say that I feel “fortunate” that my caregiving experiences were not as difficult as what some dementia caregivers experience. The primary health concerns I was dealing with were more physically related rather than dementia-related. That certainly brought its own challenges, and I would never want to minimize the experience of anyone caring for someone with significant physical health needs.

At the same time, through both my personal experiences and my work with older adults and families, I have come to appreciate that dementia can add another layer of complexity to the caregiving experience.

Caregiving of any kind can bring enormous challenges, stress, grief, uncertainty, gratitude, and even moments of learning and unexpected connection. There is no single caregiving experience, and every family brings its own history, relationships, strengths, and challenges to the role.

Anyone who willingly steps into a caregiving role—or finds themselves unexpectedly thrown into it—is taking on something significant. Caregivers are often the unsung heroes of our families and communities.

And while every caregiving situation is different, dementia caregiving can bring some particularly unique challenges and layers of complexity that can be difficult to navigate, especially as the illness progresses and the relationship itself begins to change.

The Unpredictability of Dementia

With that in mind, there are some aspects of dementia caregiving that can be particularly difficult, including the unpredictability of the disease and its progression.

Changes may happen slowly and almost imperceptibly for a period of time. Then there may be a noticeable change that suddenly requires substantially more care, attention, or supervision.

A person who was previously able to spend time alone may eventually need someone with them much of the time. What once seemed like ordinary independence can become a concern about safety.

And this can be difficult for both people.

The person living with dementia may not see the need for additional supervision. From their perspective, they may still feel perfectly capable of doing the things they have done throughout their lives.

The caregiver, however, may be seeing risks that the person with dementia cannot recognize.

This can create conflict, frustration, and sometimes resistance. It can also leave the caregiver wondering how to balance respecting the person's independence with keeping them safe.

When the Relationship Begins to Change

Perhaps one of the most difficult parts of dementia caregiving is that you may still have the person you love physically with you, while aspects of the relationship you once knew begin to change.

This can create what we call ambiguous loss—a loss that is difficult to define because the person is still present, but something about the relationship has changed.

Imagine having a spouse who once appreciated everything you did for them. As dementia progresses, they may no longer recognize your efforts. They may not acknowledge what you have done, or they may even respond in ways that are hurtful.

Those moments can be incredibly difficult.

Perhaps your relationship was built around good conversations and shared decision-making. Now communication may become limited, confusing, repetitive, or even offensive.

At one point, you may have made decisions together. Now you may find yourself making decisions on behalf of another person—or making difficult decisions that you feel completely unprepared to make.

That can be a tremendous emotional burden.

When Caregiving Becomes Personal

As dementia progresses, caregivers may also find themselves providing assistance with tasks they never imagined doing for their spouse, parent, or loved one.

Some of these tasks can feel particularly uncomfortable because they involve privacy and intimacy.

Personal hygiene, dressing, bathing, and toileting are examples. Roles that once felt clearly defined within a relationship can become blurred.

You may find yourself thinking, “This isn't how our relationship used to be.”

And that realization can bring grief.

It can be difficult to acknowledge that while the person you love is still here, parts of the relationship you shared may be changing or disappearing. There can be love, frustration, sadness, tenderness, anger, guilt and even moments of humour—all existing side by side.

The Emotional and Physical Weight of Caregiving

These are only a few of the factors that can complicate dementia caregiving.

As you can imagine—or perhaps you already know from personal experience—caregiving can become physically and emotionally draining.

There may be days when you find yourself wondering:

How much more can I handle?

How long can I keep doing this?

And sometimes that thought is immediately followed by guilt.

Feeling overwhelmed does not mean you don’t love the person you are caring for. Wanting a break does not mean you are selfish. Finding parts of caregiving difficult does not mean you are failing.

It means you are human.

Caregivers need care, too.

This is the first in a series of blogs looking more closely at the experience of caregiving. In my next blog, I’ll explore some of the feelings that can accompany this enormous responsibility and begin looking more closely at caregiver stress and caregiver burnout.

If you are caring for someone with dementia, supporting an aging parent, or navigating the complicated changes that can come with aging, you don't have to carry everything alone. Sometimes having a safe and supportive place to talk about what you're experiencing can be an important part of caring for yourself, too. https://robsmithcounselling.janeapp.com/

Rob Smith

Rob Smith

Contact Me